Fall This or That
Fall This or That: The Ultimate Game for Cozy Get-Togethers
Ahhh, fall. That magical time when the air turns crisp, your slow cooker becomes your best friend again, and everything starts tasting like pumpkin spice. Whether you’re hosting a fall birthday bash, a classroom celebration, a family game night, or just trying to keep the kids off their screens for five minutes Fall This or That is your new go-to game. It’s simple, silly, and honestly… a whole lot of fun.
As a mom who’s juggled school projects in one hand and a mug of hot cider in the other, I can tell you there’s nothing quite like a round of This or That to get everyone laughing, chatting, and bonding. It’s a sweet and simple way to enjoy each other’s company and sneak in some quality time.
What Is “This or That”?
If you’ve never played before, don’t worry it’s delightfully low-maintenance. You read two options out loud, like “Corn Maze or Hayride?” and everyone picks their favorite. That’s it. No right answers. No points. Just preferences and maybe a few surprising opinions (spoiler: apparently not everyone likes apple pie who knew?).
It’s kind of like Would You Rather’s easier cousin. Less dramatic, more cozy. And perfect for all ages.
Why This Game Works So Well in Fall
There’s something special about autumn. The slower pace, the cozy clothes, the warm comfort foods it’s the season of connection. Everyone’s a little more willing to pause, share, and play. Fall This or That fits right in with that vibe. It’s light, it’s fun, and it gets people talking without the pressure of “performing” like in some other party games.
Whether you’re playing around the dinner table or passing the time on a road trip to the pumpkin patch, this game works for:
- Family dinners
- Classroom icebreakers
- Church or youth group events
- Fall parties and Thanksgiving gatherings
- Cozy couch hangouts with hot cocoa in hand
And bonus it requires absolutely no prep. (I mean, who has time for anything that requires glue and glitter this time of year?)
How to Play
Here’s the best part you can play this game anytime, anywhere. Seriously. No materials required (unless you want to grab a printable, which I’ll share in a minute). Just pick a leader (or take turns), and start tossing out the prompts.
Example:
- “Pumpkin Pie or Apple Pie?”
- “Jump in leaves or Drink hot cocoa?”
- “Trick-or-treating or Fall crafts?”
Everyone calls out or shares their answer. You can go lightning round style (fast-paced), or take your time and let people explain their choices. (“Wait, why are you picking haunted houses over cozy movies?!”)
Printable Fall This or That Game
Want to take it up a notch? Maybe for a classroom party or Thanksgiving dinner? Check out our Thanksgiving This or That Game Printable. It’s super cute, family-friendly, and ready to print.
It’s designed for kids and adults alike, and works wonderfully as a table game while waiting for the turkey to finish or even during dessert (because we all know there’s always room for a second slice of pie).
Our Favorite Fall This or That Questions
If you’re looking to get started right away, here’s a fun list of fall-themed questions to try. You can pick a few or go through the whole list!
Food Edition
- Pumpkin spice or apple cinnamon?
- Hot chocolate or apple cider?
- Turkey or ham?
- Sweet potato casserole or mashed potatoes?
- Cornbread or dinner rolls?
- Roasted marshmallows or baked apples?
Activity Edition
- Corn maze or hayride?
- Leaf raking or pumpkin carving?
- Fall fair or fall photoshoot?
- Trick-or-treat or host a Halloween party?
- Thanksgiving Day parade or football game?
Style Edition
- Flannel or cozy sweaters?
- Beanies or wide-brim hats?
- Tall boots or fuzzy socks?
- Halloween costume or Thanksgiving outfit?
Scenery Edition
- Falling leaves or morning frost?
- Early sunsets or chilly mornings?
- Mountain hikes or forest walks?
Cozy Vibes Edition
- Read a book or watch a movie?
- Stay in or go out?
- Scented candles or essential oils?
- Baking cookies or making soup?
Want even more inspiration? We’ve rounded up some of the coziest, silliest, and most family-friendly question ideas in this Fall Would You Rather Questions post too. It’s got a bunch of gems that double as This or That prompts!
Fun Twists to Try
1. Keep Score (Just for Laughs!)
Pick a “winner” for each round by majority vote whoever guesses the most popular choice scores a point.
2. Make It a Movement Game
Have everyone stand up. When you call out the choices, point left for one answer and right for the other. Players move to the side of the room (or the backyard!) that matches their pick.
3. Add Props or Printables
For larger groups, pass out cards or hold up signs for each choice. This works especially well with younger kids or classroom groups.
4. Mix With Would You Rather
Add in some classic Would You Rather questions to spice things up. (Like these fun ideas from our Thanksgiving Would You Rather post. They’re hilarious, and surprisingly good conversation starters.)
When to Play Fall This or That
Here are some moments when this game just fits:
- During family dinners – ask a few questions while the food is still cooling
- At Thanksgiving – keep the cousins from wrestling on the carpet by handing out game cards
- On road trips – whether you’re headed to Grandma’s or the apple orchard
- In the classroom – it’s a great five-minute brain break
- During sleepovers or cozy nights in – light a candle, pour the cider, and start asking away
You don’t need a special occasion, though. One of the best parts about this game is how it turns an ordinary moment into something a little more meaningful.
Why Kids AND Adults Love It
Let’s be real games that work for both toddlers and teens are basically unicorns. But Fall This or That checks all the boxes. It’s:
✅ Easy to understand
✅ Quick to play
✅ No winners or losers
✅ Conversation-sparking
✅ Lighthearted fun
And bonus it’s screen-free, inclusive, and super customizable. You can keep it silly for the littles or add thoughtful questions for older kids and adults.
Keep It Simple, Keep It Fun
In a season that sometimes gets a little hectic (hello, back-to-school madness AND holiday prep), Fall This or That is a beautiful little reminder to pause, connect, and have a laugh. Whether you’re playing with toddlers, teens, grandparents, or a bunch of friends this game has a way of bringing people together.
So light that cinnamon candle, pour yourself something warm, and gather your people. Then ask the question that really matters: “Pumpkin patch or apple orchard?”
