Halloween Body Parts Game

Sharing is caring!

Looking for a Halloween game that’s equal parts spooky and laugh-out-loud funny? The Halloween Body Parts Game is a total classic that never fails to get shrieks, giggles, and a few “ewws!” from party guests of all ages. It’s the perfect mix of creepy and comical and the best part? It’s ridiculously easy to set up using everyday items from your kitchen.

Whether you’re planning a classroom Halloween party, a neighborhood gathering, or a family night of spooky fun, this game is a must-have addition. You’ll be passing around “body parts” that are really just harmless foods but in the dark (or with eyes closed), they feel horrifyingly real!

If you want the full spooky script, printable instructions, and food ideas all in one ready-to-go set, grab the Halloween Body Parts Game Printable here it makes hosting this game effortless and oh-so-fun.

What Is the Halloween Body Parts Game?

Imagine this: the lights are low, a ghostly story is being read aloud, and everyone’s sitting in a circle. As the storyteller describes the remains of poor Mr. John Smith, you pass around bowls filled with strange, squishy, slimy “body parts.”

The catch? Players can’t look they can only feel!

As the story unfolds, each bowl corresponds to a creepy clue like “his slimy eyes” or “his rotted brains.” Players reach in and touch each “body part,” trying not to squeal while guessing what it really is.

It’s part mystery, part gross-out fun, and 100% Halloween entertainment.

What You Need to Play

Setting up the Halloween Body Parts Game is easy, and you probably have most of the supplies already on hand. Here’s what you’ll need:

• Your Halloween Body Parts Game Printable (story + answer key)
• 8 small bowls or containers with lids (so no one can peek!)
• A few dish towels or pillowcases to cover the bowls if they’re open
• A blindfold (optional, if you want extra mystery)
• Paper towels or wipes for cleanup things are going to get gooey!
• A brave storyteller with their best spooky voice

Food Ideas for the “Body Parts”

Here’s what you’ll use for each “body part” in the story. You can swap a few items if needed, but the classic combos below never fail to give the perfect creepy texture!

Tip: Label the bottom of each bowl with the food name so you don’t forget which is which once things get dark.

Setting the Scene

The secret to making this game unforgettable? It’s all about the atmosphere.

Here’s how to turn your space into the perfect setting for your creepy storytime:

1. Dim the lights – or turn them off completely and play by flashlight or candlelight (battery-operated candles work best for safety).
2. Add spooky sounds – think creaky doors, howling wind, or distant thunder. You can find free Halloween soundtracks online or on YouTube.
3. Gather everyone in a circle – this helps the bowls pass easily and keeps the suspense high.
4. Have your storyteller ready – bonus points if they wear a cloak or witch’s hat and use a dramatic, eerie voice.

The Story of Mr. John Smith

Now comes the fun part – the spooky story!

Your printable includes the full version of the Halloween Body Parts Game story, so all you have to do is read it aloud as you pass each bowl around the circle. Here’s how it goes:

Once on a dark night like this,
a man by the name of Mr. John Smith
was murdered and his body thrown away,
but we have brought him back today.

To you we will pass on his remains,
starting now with his rotted brains.

As you read that line, pass the bowl of cooked cauliflower around and let everyone touch it. The reactions are usually priceless – you’ll hear shrieks, nervous laughter, and maybe a few brave souls trying to guess out loud!

Then continue:

Next we found his slimy eyes,
buried down deep and small in size.

Pass the peeled grapes or olives – this one always gets the biggest “Eww!” of the night.

The story continues as you reveal his intestines (spaghetti), skin (orange rind), hair (yarn), heart (tomato), nose (chicken bone), and ears (dried apricots) – all while keeping the lights low and the suspense high.

When the story ends, you can turn on the lights and reveal what everyone was really touching. That moment when they realize the “brain” was cauliflower? Absolutely hilarious!

How to Play

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown for hosting your own Halloween Body Parts Game:

1. Prepare your bowls – Fill each bowl with the correct “body part” food and label them on the bottom.
2. Set up your space – Dim the lights, cue the spooky music, and have your storyteller ready.
3. Gather the players – Sit everyone in a circle and explain that they must not peek. They’ll hear the story and touch each “body part” as it’s mentioned.
4. Begin the story – Read the script slowly, with pauses for dramatic effect. Pass each bowl as you reach that part of the story.
5. Encourage reactions – Let everyone squeal, laugh, or make their guesses out loud – that’s half the fun!
6. Reveal the truth – When the story ends, turn on the lights and show everyone what they were really touching. Expect lots of relieved laughter and “I knew it!” moments.

Tips for Hosting Success

• Keep it age-appropriate: For younger kids, tone down the scary voice and use silly sound effects instead. For teens and adults, go full haunted-house mode!
• Add prizes: Give a small prize to the player who correctly guesses the most “body parts.”
• Make cleanup easy: Use disposable gloves or zip-top bags inside bowls for quick cleanup afterward.
• Encourage participation: Even shy guests usually end up laughing once they see everyone else joining in.
• Pair it with another game: After the creepy story, keep the fun going with a Halloween trivia quiz, mummy wrap race, or spooky bingo.

Why Everyone Loves This Game

The Halloween Body Parts Game has been around for decades – and for good reason! It’s a perfect mix of imagination, sensory play, and pure silliness.

• For kids: It’s spooky but not too scary, and they love guessing the “gross” foods.
• For teens: It’s a great icebreaker at parties or sleepovers.
• For adults: Add a little extra drama (and maybe some themed snacks) and you’ve got a hilarious Halloween hit.

It’s one of those rare games that works in just about any setting a classroom, community hall, or even your living room. And the printable version makes it effortless to host, with the full story and food guide ready to go.

Get the Printable Game

Want to make your party planning easy as pumpkin pie?

You can grab the Halloween Body Parts Game Printable here. It includes:

• The complete spooky story of Mr. John Smith
• Matching food ideas for each “body part”
• Clear instructions for setup and play
• A cute printable design you can reuse year after year

It’s perfect for teachers, parents, or anyone hosting a Halloween bash and it instantly adds that “wow” factor to your event.

Make It a Full Halloween Experience

If you want to turn your Halloween night into something extra special, try pairing this game with:

• Pumpkin carving or a pumpkin toss game
• Monster cookie decorating
• A spooky photo booth with silly props
• DIY treat bags filled with Halloween candy

You could even end the night with a Halloween movie and snacks because after touching fake brains and guts, everyone deserves something sweet!

The Halloween Body Parts Game is the kind of tradition that never gets old. It’s spooky enough to thrill the kids, funny enough to make adults laugh, and simple enough that anyone can play.

It’s hands-on, hilarious, and guaranteed to be the highlight of your Halloween party. So grab your bowls, your spooky voice, and your printable story from LittleHaloJ.com, and get ready for a night full of chills, giggles, and memories your guests will still be talking about next year.

Happy haunting, friends and may Mr. John Smith rest in pieces!

Sharing is caring!